A Comprehensive Review of Sequence and Generative Models in Motor Imagery (MI) Classification for Brain–Computer Interfaces (BCIs)
TL;DR
This study performs an in-depth analysis on the strengths and limitations of traditional models such as RNNs and LSTMs as well as emergent models such as VAEs and transformers, which have demonstrated superior performance in extracting the intricate patterns of the EEG data with low latency.
Abstract
Motor imagery (MI) classification serves as the backbone to brain–computer interfaces (BCIs) by strengthening the communication bridge between the human brain and external peripheral devices. The past two decades have witnessed unprecedented success in MI-BCIs, with applications not only in medical fields but also in several other domains, such as gaming and robotic control. Initially, MI classification primarily relied on classical signal processing techniques that were heavily impacted by signal variations; however, recent trends in deep learning (DL), specifically in sequence-oriented, attention-based, hybrid, and generative architectures such as recurrent neural networks (RNNs), variational autoencoders (VAEs), generative adversarial networks (GANs), and transformers have significantly improved the efficiency and robustness of MI classification. This study presents a comprehensive review of these sequence-oriented, attention-based, hybrid, and generative architectures including RNNs, VAEs, GANs, and transformers, comparing their robustness across various public MI datasets, highlighting their challenges, such as inter-subject variation, low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and the obstacles in real-time signal classification. We perform an in-depth analysis on the strengths and limitations of traditional models such as RNNs and LSTMs as well as emergent models such as VAEs and transformers, which have demonstrated superior performance in extracting the intricate patterns of the EEG data with low latency. Moreover, we critically examine the future potential of such models in overcoming current bottlenecks, such as weak generalization on unseen data and high computational load. This study aims to assist researchers in attaining significant insights into the state-of-the-art sequence, attention-based, hybrid, and generative models used in MI classification, thus offering a direction for future innovation.