Sep 2026· AI & SOCIETY· 0 citations· 55 references
TL;DR
CAI’s inability to provide necessary resistance or survive aggression prevents the transformative psychological development found in the human therapeutic encounter, and it is suggested that the encounter with the paradox of pleasing ultimately serves to foreground the unique and indispensable nature of human therapeutic recognition.
Abstract
Conversational artificial intelligence (CAI) is increasingly used by hundreds of millions of people for emotional support, personal advice, and therapeutic purposes, rapidly emerging as a mediator of human self-understanding (Stade et al. 2025). Yet despite growing evidence of systematic user-validation in CAI, documented as “sycophancy” in the AI safety literature (Sharma et al. 2024), its implications for how individuals come to understand themselves remain largely unexamined. This article addresses that gap by reframing sycophancy not as a technical alignment failure or a purely philosophical concern, but as a failure of recognition in the psychoanalytic and critical-theoretical sense. We identify a core tension we term the “paradox of pleasing”: CAI’s drive to please renders it structurally unable to provide the friction, conflict, and encounter with otherness that genuine recognition requires. Drawing on Winnicott’s (1960, 1971) concepts of “holding” and “object use,” we contend that CAI’s inability to provide necessary resistance or survive aggression prevents the transformative psychological development found in the human therapeutic encounter. Extending this analysis through Honneth’s (1995) theory of recognition and Whitebook’s (2001a, 2021) critique of Honneth, we argue that CAI reflects the undervaluing of the “work of the negative.” This limitation risks flattening consciousness by converting collective political frustration into privatized, soothed affect, undermining the conditions for critical social thought. The article concludes by suggesting that the encounter with the paradox of pleasing ultimately serves to foreground the unique and indispensable nature of human therapeutic recognition.
An integrative narrative review of interdisciplinary evidence on AI psychological companionship concludes that AI companions are consequential relational technologies whose net effect on public mental health will depend on deliberate scientific, ethical, and regulatory choices.
Sofia Elias, Nurul Aisyah Kamrozzaman· International journal of res...· 0 citations
The paper develops two distinctions, between interaction and co-experience and between a relational mirror and a relational source, which suggest AI companionship has real value and belongs to a category distinct from relationships grounded in mutual inner stakes and an autonomous inner life.
Through the lens of an updated Dull, Dirty, and Dangerous (D3) framework, this perspective piece offers a way of navigating human-AI collaboration in psychotherapy and the likely risks that might occur in practice.
Nathaniel Swinger, Cynthia M. Baseman, Rosa I. Arriaga· Frontiers in Human Dynamics· 0 citations
Artificial intelligence chatbots and conversational agents are being used more and more often to provide emotional support in mental health. A scoping review of interdisciplinary studies published from 2018 to 2025 was conducted to identify structural and functional deficiencies in emotional AI for mental health suppor...
Liu-Ting-Yu-Zhou-Feng Xiao· Journal of Education and Edu...· 0 citations
Emotion is rarely at the top of the list when we discuss the role of Generative AI in computer science education and in computing spaces broadly. With AI demonstrating increasingly sophisticated abilities to code, many have adopted a sense of dismay about the prospects for training young computer scientists. In this pi...
Murtaza Ali· ACM Transactions on Computin...· 0 citations
The change has created a fertile context for AI-powered grieftech, and the article concludes with reflections on the new grief work and tech interaction.
Joseph E. Davis· Social research· 1 citation
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.