Skip to content
Open access

Human learning of probability distributions is biased toward moderate structural complexity

Aug 2026 · Nature Communications · Vol 17 · 0 citations · 80 references
Medicine

TL;DR

The authors show that individuals are biased towards building models with moderate structural complexity, regardless of true complexity, and reconstruct the prior beliefs guiding the evolution of participants’ internal representations.

Abstract

Inferring hidden environmental structures, which commonly involves learning arbitrary probability distributions from limited samples, is essential to optimal and adaptive behaviors across various cognitive domains. However, it remains largely unknown how the internal representations constructed by humans may deviate from actual probabilistic structures, and what computational processes, operated under inherent cognitive limitations, give rise to these representations. We first develop a structured distribution report task to reveal human participants’ internal representations, with findings verified in a further distribution recognition task. Across eight behavioral experiments (including one pre-registered study) in two modalities, participants estimate the overall probability density reasonably well, but exhibit a systematic bias toward moderate structural complexity, reporting too many clusters when the true distribution is a single Gaussian and too few when it contains many clusters. We then build a series of learning models in the framework of approximate Bayesian inference fit to our behavioral data. Through model comparisons, we reconstruct the prior beliefs guiding the evolution of participants’ internal representations. The best-fitting model for human reports reduces structure growth rate as complexity increases, effectively constraining the complexity of internal representations within memory limitations. Humans build internal models from online observations to adapt to new environments. Here, the authors show that individuals are biased towards building models with moderate structural complexity, regardless of true complexity.

Read PDF

Similar papers

#artificial intelligence Preprint Aug 2026

Probing Perceptual Priors of MLLMs via Gibbs Sampling with Interpretable Generative Controls

This work proposes a method to sample from models'perceptual prior distributions directly, by steering a generative model to produce stimuli along controllable axes and running Gibbs sampling over that space with the model under study as the judge, and recovers both canonical biases and surprising novel priors invisibl...

Manuel Cherep, Pattie Maes, Nikhil Singh · 2 citations
Preprint Sep 2026

Neural noise enables accurate internal simulation of rare events

The brain needs an accurate internal model of the world to generate predictions and guide behavior. However, it must estimate the statistical structure of the environment from limited experience. This is particularly difficult for rare events, whose observed frequencies in a limited sample may substantially under- or o...

Heng-Zhi Zhang, Pawel Herman, Zenas C. Chao · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Dynamic Reduction of Neural Uncertainty Shapes Perceptual Decisions in a Bayes-Optimal Manner

The findings support and extend the idea that the brain implements iterative Bayesian inference to navigate the environment in an adaptive manner which offers a general and unifying mathematical framework for cognition.

Dragan Rangelov, Sebastian Bitzer, Jason B. Mattingley · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Predictive perception via simultaneous learning and inference

Perception has been proposed to involve an inferential process that combines noisy sensory evidence with prior expectations to estimate the latent states of the environment. Exact Bayesian inference is intractable in the continuous, high-dimensional state spaces of the natural world. Variational schemes address this by...

M. Enan, M. Senden, Paulina Janik et al. · 1 citation
#machine learning Preprint Aug 2026

Learning the Geometry of Admissible Hypotheses through Inductive Bias in Training Distributions

This work presents a framework for learning continuous latent representations of admissible partial differential equations by embedding a scientific inductive bias directly into the training distribution, and shows that embedding a scientific inductive bias in the training distribution enables the learning of compact a...

James Crowley, Faez Ahmed, A. van Beek · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Prior-Likelihood Metamers to Distinguish Strategies Underlying Human Bayesian Behaviour in Perception

Bayesian decision theory proposes that people make statistically rational decisions by combining prior knowledge with sensory information (likelihoods). This framework successfully explains many aspects of human behaviour. However, debate persists over whether people perform precise Bayesian computations (i.e., explici...

Chin-Hsuan Sophie Lin, N. Terence, M. Garrido · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.