It is argued that microbiome function should be interpreted as a hierarchy of inferences rather than a single property, and functional studies should explicitly state whether their conclusions concern capacity, realization, or impact, thereby clarifying the evidential basis of functional claims and improving their interpretation and comparison across microbiome studies.
Abstract
Microbiome research has moved from cataloging community composition to asking what these communities do, but “function” is often used to describe fundamentally different levels of evidence. Functional claims may refer to functional capacity (what is encoded), functional realization (what molecular functions are actively engaged under specific conditions), or functional impact (the resulting consequences for hosts, microbial communities, or ecosystems). In this Perspective, we examine how functional annotations in microbiome research generate biological meaning and why current approaches support different kinds of inference. We propose a framework that distinguishes three levels of functional inference: capacity, realization, and impact. Homology-based, domain-centric, pathway-based, machine learning-driven, and multi-omics approaches each contribute differently to these levels, but none alone captures microbiome function in full. We argue that microbiome function should be interpreted as a hierarchy of inferences rather than a single property. Recognizing this distinction should improve how functional findings are interpreted, reported, and compared across microbiome studies. Accordingly, functional studies should explicitly state whether their conclusions concern capacity, realization, or impact, thereby clarifying the evidential basis of functional claims and improving their interpretation and comparison across microbiome studies.
Functional redundancy is a key biological concept that offers critical insights into microbial ecosystem stability and responses to environmental perturbations. Existing methods to quantify redundancy typically rely on gene annotations as functional units, limiting their ability to capture complex or partially...
Sofia Fraulini, D. Sanguineti, Guido Zampieri et al.· Methods in Ecology and Evolu...· 0 citations
This Review presents microbiome foundation models as a hierarchy spanning biological scales, and proposes a transition from static representation learning toward intervention‐aware microbiome world models capable of simulation, digital twinning, and generative microbiome engineering.
Hao-Hong Zhang, Zi-Xin Kang, K. Ning· Advanced genetics· 0 citations
'core microbiome' should be reserved for microbial components explicitly demonstrated to be conserved across defined spatial, temporal, and environmental dimensions and linked to conserved ecological functions, while taxa selected for explanatory value are better described as 'explanatory subsets of taxa'.
Jaejin Lee, Bolívar Aponte Rolón, Phillip de Lorimier et al.· New Phytologist· 1 citation
Microbial communities are highly diverse, making it difficult to distinguish stable ecological patterns from stochastic variation. The core microbiome offers a widely used framework for simplification, but prevalence-based definitions are often criticized for relying on arbitrary thresholds. We propose an alternative v...
Camilo Quiroga-González, L. Prada-Salcedo, K. Goldmann· bioRxiv· 0 citations
This work leverage 1,150 complete genomes to construct genome-scale metabolic models, demonstrating that draft assemblies introduce systematic artifacts and omit critical transport functions, and connects genome completeness with microbial ecological organization and provides a framework for linking metabolic interacti...
Yu-He Gu, Haoyu Wang, Jin-Long Yang et al.· Cell Reports· 0 citations
This review synthesizes current mechanistic and translational evidence to conceptualize the gut microbiome as an organ‐like functional system, delineate its structural and functional organization, and propose a framework for mapping, modeling, and therapeutically targeting microbiome‐derived circuits to support precisi...
Yang Bi, Wei-Bin Song, Maria Glymenaki et al.· iMeta· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.