Skip to content
Open access

Evolutionary relatedness is a partially reliable predictor of host-associated microbiome composition

Sep 2026 · bioRxiv · 0 citations · 41 references
Biology

TL;DR

This work leveraged the diversity of Insecta, arisen from 400 My of evolution, to evaluate if microbiome evolution is synchronized with the evolutionary history of their associated hosts and found that host evolution plays a limited role in predicting microbiome composition.

Abstract

Multicellular animals emerged into a microbial world and they continue to be influenced by sympatric bacterial species. Host-associated microbiomes are recognized as critical contributors to their living domicile’s success. Detailing how microbiomes are assembled and maintained by their hosts has important implications for animal health, agricultural productivity, and biodiversity interventions across the tree of life. 10s-100s of bacterial genera are frequently detected in animal microbiomes, with some being uniquely and consistently detected in specific host species. Such discoveries have informed theories like phylosymbiosis that assert that host-associated microbiomes often reflect host species relatedness. We explored the predictive limits of this theory by performing a multi-scale dissimilarity-based comparative analyses using publicly-available microbiomes drawn from 113 insect species spanning 14 insect orders. We detected a moderate inter-order phylosymbiotic signal (Mantel test: r = 0.392, p<0.001) that was weakened (r = 0.173, p<0.001) when the Blattodea were excluded from the analysis. Intra-order level phylosymbiotic signals were detected for lepidopteran, hymenopteran, hemipteran, and blattodean host species microbiomes. These signals were often explained by obligate endosymbionts and/or nestmate-acquired gut bacteria, rather than by the total microbiomes. Host species-defining bacterial genera often represented a fraction of the total observed microbial diversity in their respective insect host species. We hypothesize that members of insect orders can exhibit considerable microbiome compositional variability where host speciation events may be minimally reflected in their microbiomes taxonomic membership, but host species-defining bacterial genera are likely when host behaviors or physiologies that facilitate reliable intra- and inter-generational bacterial transmission or acquisition are present. IMPORTANCE While all animals have microbiomes, the principles determining their composition remain an incomplete story. We leveraged the diversity of Insecta, arisen from 400 My of evolution, to evaluate if microbiome evolution is synchronized with the evolutionary history of their associated hosts. We found that host evolution plays a limited role in predicting microbiome composition, particularly due to non-uniformity of host-microbial symbioses across insects. While Blattodea in particular harbor exceptionally diverse microbiomes, many insect guts are characterized by few bacterial genera. Our results suggest that host evolutionary history is but one of many factors, including differences in microbiome transmission modality, influencing insect microbiome evolution.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Giant bacteria in gut microbiomes

The advent of sequencing-based omics has transformed our understanding of the gut microbiome, enabling microbial communities to be characterised at unprecedented scale and resolution1,2. However, these approaches provide limited information about cellular traits such as size and morphology. Giant bacteria remain largel...

Yiang Lyu, Marit Grüner, A. Klein et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Bacterial dispersal and host specificity shape microbiome strain sharing among great ape species in neighboring zoo exhibits

Animal microbiomes often exhibit host-species-specific structure, which could suggest a shared evolutionary history with their hosts. However, in wild populations this possibility has been difficult to disentangle from geographic or ecological barriers to microbial dispersal, particularly in taxa like non-human primate...

P. Krauss, Antonia Breier, A. Hohlfeld et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Rethinking the soil core microbiome.

'core microbiome' should be reserved for microbial components explicitly demonstrated to be conserved across defined spatial, temporal, and environmental dimensions and linked to conserved ecological functions, while taxa selected for explanatory value are better described as 'explanatory subsets of taxa'.

Jaejin Lee, Bolívar Aponte Rolón, Phillip de Lorimier et al. · 1 citation
Open access Sep 2026

The core microbiome as a reproducible, data-driven abstraction, not a biological entity

Microbial communities are highly diverse, making it difficult to distinguish stable ecological patterns from stochastic variation. The core microbiome offers a widely used framework for simplification, but prevalence-based definitions are often criticized for relying on arbitrary thresholds. We propose an alternative v...

Camilo Quiroga-González, L. Prada-Salcedo, K. Goldmann · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Integrative holo-omic data analysis predicts interactions across the host-microbiome axis

It is shown that a computational method designed for multi-omic analysis in eukaryotes can be leveraged to integrate and analyze five layers of holo-omic data from porcine hosts and their gut microbiomes, and predicts new leads for understanding host-microbiome symbiosis.

J. Merkesvik, J. Langa, C. Pietroni et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Seven gut microbiome types across two Japanese cohorts defined by co-abundance-based microbial guilds and associated with host physiology

Collectively, co-abundance-defined microbial guilds capture coherent ecological and functional states of the gut microbiota, providing a transferable framework for linking gut microbiome organization to host physiology beyond conventional taxonomy-based classification.

Jiro Nakayama, Misako Yoden, Ayaka Uchikawa et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.