Skip to content
Open access

Linear and Nonlinear Econometric Models versus Machine-Learning Models: Evidence from Realized-Volatility Forecasting

Sep 2026 · Finance and Economics Discussion Series · 0 citations

TL;DR

A robust horizon-dependent ranking is revealed: Markov-switching HAR performs best at short horizons, ARFIMA generally leads at the monthly horizon, and the five-day horizon is intermediate, and forecast performance depends primarily on capturing the persistence and nonlinear dynamics most relevant at each horizon.

Abstract

This paper examines which representations of persistence and nonlinearity are most useful for forecasting realized volatility and whether machine learning adds value beyond econometric models designed for long memory and regime dependence. We compare HAR, ARFIMA, threshold HAR, smooth-transition HAR, and Markov-switching HAR with XGBoost and several neural-network models for the S\&P~500 and 40 U.S. equities. Models are evaluated under a baseline information set using realized-volatility history and an extended set of predictors selected by Elastic Net. Forecast performance is assessed using MSFE, MAE, QLIKE, Model Confidence Sets, Diebold--Mariano tests, realized utility, and filtered-historical-simulation VaR and expected shortfall. The results reveal a robust horizon-dependent ranking: Markov-switching HAR performs best at short horizons, ARFIMA generally leads at the monthly horizon, and the five-day horizon is intermediate. Machine-learning models sometimes improve on HAR but do not systematically outperform the broader econometric set. These findings are robust across estimation windows, re-estimation frequencies, richer information sets, log-volatility targets, and individual equities; stock-level results are also robust to an alternative realized-volatility measure. Overall, forecast performance depends primarily on capturing the persistence and nonlinear dynamics most relevant at each horizon.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Statistical and Economic Comparisons of Econometric, Linear, and Machine Learning Models

This study compares econometric, linear regression, and machine-learning models for forecasting five-day close-to-close volatility across 12 diversified US exchange-traded funds. The dataset covers 2,511 trading days from September 2016 to August 2026 and includes equities, bonds, precious metals, commodities, and real...

Suganya Eliot, Muthulakshmi Angamuthu · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Volatility forecasting with econometric and machine learning models under capacity control

This study evaluates multiple forecasting models, ranging from HAR and GARCH to Tree-based and Neural architectures, across 14 Global Equity Indices and Horizons form 1 day to 100 Trading days within a strictly chronological and capacity-controlled framework, indicating that for strongly dependent time series, nominal...

Animesh Jha, Mainak Bandyopadhyay · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Forecasting Multivariate Time Series: A Comparison of Machine Learning, Statistical and Deep Learning Models

The findings demonstrate that rigorous leakage-free validation is essential for reliable forecasting research and that, for monthly Robusta coffee prices, increased model complexity does not necessarily yield superior predictive performance.

Dler H Kadir, D. Khalil, Azhin M. Khudhur · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Models for real-time nowcasting and forecasting of GDP components by expenditure

Which family of models and which particular models are the most accurate for relatively short time series are asked, which approaches should be developed further, and why machine learning still yields no substantial gain over advanced econometric methods are compared are compared.

N. Fokin · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

WHICH MODEL FAMILIES PAY? ECONOMETRIC, GRADIENT BOOSTING AND RECURRENT NEURAL NETWORK VOLATILITY FORECASTS IN ACTIVE TRADING STRATEGIES ON THE RUSSIAN STOCK MARKET

This paper asks which families of volatility forecasting models create economic value in active trading, and through which integration channel that value is transmitted, and which is governed by the integration channel rather than by the size of the accuracy gain.

Nikita I. Lysenok · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Neural and Econometric Forecasting of Market Risk: A Comparative Value-at-Risk and Expected-Shortfall Analysis Across Global Equity Markets

This study evaluates whether a deep-learning volatility model improves market-risk measurement relative to established econometric benchmarks. Using daily returns for twelve developed and emerging equity indices from January 2000 to September 2026—with the KSE-100 and IMOEX series taken from the Pakistan Stock Exchange...

Raima Amjad, Arshad Hassan, Zeeshan Ahmed · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.