Skip to content
Open access

Teachers’ and learners’ perspectives on disciplinary approaches in a South African special school through an inclusive education Lens

Sep 2026 · Frontiers in Education · 0 citations · 55 references

Abstract

Inclusive education seeks to promote learner participation, belonging, and responsiveness to diversity. However, despite growing scholarship on inclusive education and behaviour support, limited research has examined how disciplinary approaches in special schools align with or contradict the principles of inclusive education. This study addresses this gap by exploring disciplinary approaches employed in a South African special school through an inclusive education lens. Within an interpretivist paradigm, the study adopted a single-case qualitative design. Data were originally generated through semi-structured interviews with four teachers and a focus group discussion with six learners. The existing dataset underwent a secondary, theory-informed thematic analysis that combined deductive and inductive coding. The findings showed that disciplinary practices could not be understood as inherently inclusive or exclusionary. Structured rules, monitoring, behavioural accountability, and privilege systems were used to promote order, safety, and behavioural regulation, while relational support, learner voice, praise, recognition, and professional judgement shaped participation and belonging in varied ways. Importantly, the same practice could support some learners while generating experiences of control, unfairness, or exclusion for others. The study contributes to inclusive education scholarship by refining the application of the inclusion–exclusion continuum to disciplinary practices in a special-school context. The findings suggest that the implications of disciplinary practices depend on their purpose, enactment, context, and learners’ experiences. Inclusive disciplinary practice, therefore, requires balancing accountability with learner voice, responsiveness, fairness, dignity, support, and a sense of belonging.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Professional learning communities for inclusive pedagogy

Collaboration is widely recognized as essential for implementing inclusive education, yet teachers are frequently hindered in their efforts to develop inclusive practices by structural and cultural conditions. This article examines how professional learning communities (PLCs) function as spaces where teachers and learn...

W. Kimani · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Attitudes of general education teachers toward the inclusion of learners with diverse needs in public school

This study examined the attitudes of general education teachers toward the inclusion of learners with diverse needs in San Miguel Elementary School as a basis for developing a proposed inclusive training program during the school year 2025-2026. Specifically, it explored teachers’ awareness of inclusive education, perc...

Rochelle Cuay · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Embracing Every Learner: Exploring Strategies and Support Systems for Inclusive Education

This study aimed to explore the implementation of inclusive education for students with disabilities at Waukegan High School in Waukegan, Illinois, focusing on teachers’ lived experiences, instructional strategies, perceived effectiveness, and institutional support systems that shaped inclusive practices in the 2025 –...

Reymond Dela Cruz · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

The impact of curriculum differentiation on learner performance, participation, and engagement among foundation phase learners in rural South African Public schools

This study examined the impact of curriculum differentiation on learner performance, participation, and engagement among Foundation Phase learners in rural South African public schools. Despite policy commitments to inclusive education, many rural classrooms continue to implement uniform teaching approaches that inadeq...

Paul M. Tshisikhawe, M. Sikhwari, N. E. Thenga · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Exploring Inclusive Practices Implementation in Teacher Education: Basis for Curriculum Integration Framework

This study examined inclusive practices in teacher education using a convergent parallel mixed‑methods design. It assessed pre‑service teachers’ perceptions of institutional support, awareness, attitudes, and implementation of inclusive practices, and developed an evidence‑based framework. Quantitative data from 360 pr...

L. G. Manalo, Mary Argie Lyn Soriano · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Mapping Variations in Inclusive Teaching Practices: A Phenomenographic Study Toward a Contextualized Inclusive Instructional Framework in Zamboanga City Public Schools

Inclusive education remains a central priority in educational reform, yet teachers may understand and enact inclusion in qualitatively different ways. This study explored variations in public-school teachers’ conceptions and practices of inclusive teaching for learners with special educational needs in Zamboanga City....

Melba Gonzales · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.