ForkSCOPE: Charting the Agentic Garden of Forking Paths

Abstract

Even with a fixed dataset and research question, data analysis involves many defensible decisions. Understanding how these choices influence the results is scientifically important but remains challenging. Crowdsourcing and agentic AI can generate hundreds of end-to-end analyses, but scaling generation alone can create a processing bottleneck and an analytic ``black hole.'' A common workaround is to impose a shared fixed decision taxonomy, which can limit insight and understate uncertainty. We present ForkSCOPE, a human-AI collaboration framework that induces structure bottom-up from the code corpus of end-to-end analyses, without a taxonomy fixed before or after generation, so the organization and evaluation of the garden can scale with the corpus. ForkSCOPE surfaces the charted garden of forking paths through a human-AI collaboration pipeline and an evidence-linked interactive viewer for steering and verification: it spotlights organically identified forks and structures and produces a derived taxonomy and decision map compatible with existing multiverse tools.