Error Propagation Analysis in Multi-Person Fall Detection: A System-Level Perspective
Fall detection in multi-person environments, such as nursing homes and rehabilitation centers, is essential for ensuring the safety of vulnerable populations. Despite advances in deep learning, current vision- and skeleton-based fall detection systems often exhibit false negatives and reduced reliability in real-world scenarios due to scene complexity. This study presents a system-level analysis of fall detection errors by comparing four approaches—two skeleton-based methods using ST-GCN and ProtoGCN, a rule-based method, and a VIRA-GCN-based 3D joint method—on 95 RGB video sequences captured under minimally constrained multi-person conditions. We define six error types: skeleton structural interference, localized joint recognition failure, temporal skeleton identity inconsistency, object-to-skeleton association failure, viewpoint-induced observation limitation, and action-level ambiguity with similar activities. Although most methods achieved high event-level recall, their false-positive and false-negative patterns differed. The rule-based approach showed the most balanced performance, under the present experimental conditions, whereas the ST-GCN-based skeleton approach was more sensitive to joint-level and tracking instability. ProtoGCN reduced false positives but increased false negatives, showing a more conservative decision pattern. The VIRA-GCN-based 3D joint approach provided spatial cues but did not eliminate upstream pose and tracking errors. These results highlight the need for skeleton–depth fusion, robust identity tracking, occlusion handling, and enhanced joint recognition in real-world multi-person fall detection.